Langevin's sonar hunts submarines
“From 1915 to 1918 Paul Langevin, on Constantin Chilowsky's idea, used vibrating quartz to send ultrasound under water and hear its echo: the first active sonar, ready just after the war ended.”
In the First World War the German U-boat was almost invisible. A submerged submarine could be heard, faintly, with underwater microphones called hydrophones, but a listening ship had to stop its engines, and it learned only a rough direction, never the distance. In February 1915 a Russian engineer living in Paris, Constantin Chilowsky, sent the French government a new idea through the mathematician Paul Painlevé: send a beam of high-pitched sound, too high for the ear, into the water and listen for its echo. The time the echo took would give the range, and a narrow beam would give the direction. The idea went to Paul Langevin, a physicist at the School of Physics and Chemistry in Paris who had been a doctoral student of Pierre Curie.
Langevin thought Chilowsky's way of making the sound would not work and built his own. From March 1915 his laboratory tried an electric condenser with a thin sheet of mica, driven by a naval radio transmitter, and early in 1916 sent clear signals across the Seine near the Pont National. In April 1916 the navy moved the work to the naval base at Toulon, where in January 1917 the team heard its first echo, from an armour plate about 200 metres away. The apparatus was delicate and the microphone receivers unreliable. In February 1917 Langevin turned to piezoelectricity, discovered by Pierre and Jacques Curie in 1880: a quartz crystal gives off electricity when it is squeezed, and changes shape when a voltage is applied. A slice of quartz from the Curies' own apparatus worked at once as a receiver, and by April it was sending sound as well.
Through 1917 Langevin turned the crystal into a practical device: a mosaic of thin quartz pieces glued between two steel plates, a 'sandwich' that rang at about 40,000 vibrations a second and served as both loudspeaker and ear. Its beam was strong enough to kill fish that swam into it. In February 1918 it carried signals eight kilometres and returned, for the first time, clear echoes from a submarine. In trials off Toulon between 5 June and 8 July 1918 a ship moving at five knots found a submerged submarine at 600 to 1,300 metres and knew both its bearing and its range. The British, briefed by the French in 1917, built their own quartz sets under the Canadian physicist Robert Boyle and A. B. Wood, the work later called ASDIC, and the Americans worked on it too. In October 1918 an inter-allied conference in Paris agreed that echo-ranging was the way forward. But the French Navy's first six sets were ready only after the armistice of 11 November 1918: the war ended before sonar hunted a single U-boat.
The invention came into its own in the next war. Britain's ASDIC, built on the same quartz principle, went to sea in the 1920s and was the main weapon of the escorts in the Battle of the Atlantic; the Americans called it sonar. Langevin's quartz sandwich also gave the world modern ultrasonics: his 1918 patent already imagined medical uses, and the same idea, a crystal that sends a pulse and listens for its echo, sounds the depth of the oceans, maps the sea floor and shows an unborn child on a screen.
What happened
- 1915
Constantin Chilowsky, a Russian engineer in Paris, submits to the French government, through Paul Painlevé, a plan to detect submarines with a beam of high-frequency sound made from radio-frequency currents. It is passed to the physicist Paul Langevin.
Langevin proposes to the navy that the research be done in his laboratory at the School of Physics and Chemistry, using a mica condenser and the navy's idle radio arc transmitters, run by Captain Colin.
School of Physics and Chemistry (ESPCI), rue Vauquelin, Paris: Langevin's laboratory, where the work began in 1915The first strong beam of ultrasound is measured in the laboratory by the push it gives a small paddle on a torsion pendulum: some tenths of a watt for every square centimetre. Marcel Tournier joins the work in September.
School of Physics and Chemistry (ESPCI), rue Vauquelin, Paris: Langevin's laboratory, where the work began in 1915- 1916
Early in 1916 signals are sent across the Seine just below the Pont National, from the pinnace Caducée moored by the Popp factory to a microphone on the far bank. They come through clearly, and the navy asks for the work to move to the sea.
Pont National, Paris: the first underwater signals were sent across the Seine just below the bridgeThe Langevin-Colin mission starts work at Toulon with two vessels, one for sending and one for receiving. Chilowsky leaves the research this spring after disagreements with Langevin.
Toulon naval base: the sea trials from April 1916, the first echo from a submarine in February 1918 and the official trials of June-July 1918Chilowsky and Langevin file their French patent (502,913) on directed underwater signals and the location of underwater obstacles.
- 1917
Off Toulon the team hears its first clear echo, from a sheet of armour plate set about 200 metres from the ship.
Toulon naval base: the sea trials from April 1916, the first echo from a submarine in February 1918 and the official trials of June-July 1918Tired of unreliable microphones, Langevin tries a slice of piezoelectric quartz, taken from the Curies' own apparatus, as a receiver. It works at once.
Langevin finds the same quartz can also send: a voltage makes the crystal vibrate. A large slab gives a beam so strong that fish swimming into it die and a hand put in the water hurts.
At the end of May Ernest Rutherford and Commander Bridge of the Royal Navy come to Paris and are told about the quartz results; Britain and France begin to share their work.
Chilowsky and Langevin file their American patent; it is granted in 1923.
Robert Boyle, the Canadian physicist leading Britain's echo work, visits Toulon. This month Langevin glues a quartz slice to a steel plate, the design behind all British asdic transducers of the war.
Toulon naval base: the sea trials from April 1916, the first echo from a submarine in February 1918 and the official trials of June-July 1918A quartz receiver fitted to the vessel 'Vigoureaux' hears signals from the mica senders up to six kilometres away. By the end of the year Langevin has his final design: a mosaic of quartz between two steel plates.
Toulon naval base: the sea trials from April 1916, the first echo from a submarine in February 1918 and the official trials of June-July 1918- 1918
The first quartz-steel 'sandwich' sets are tried at sea: signals reach eight kilometres and, for the first time, clear echoes come back from a submarine.
Toulon naval base: the sea trials from April 1916, the first echo from a submarine in February 1918 and the official trials of June-July 1918Official trials of a service prototype begin off Toulon and run to 8 July. Moving at five knots, the ship finds a submerged submarine at 600 to 1,300 metres, with its bearing and range. Boyle visits again in June.
Toulon naval base: the sea trials from April 1916, the first echo from a submarine in February 1918 and the official trials of June-July 1918Langevin files the quartz patent (French patent 505,703) in his name alone; it foresees medical uses of ultrasound.
At an inter-allied conference in Paris on detecting submarines by 'supersonics', France, Britain and the United States share their results; Langevin's account is dated 31 October. The delegates agree to concentrate on echo-ranging.
The armistice ends the war. The French Navy has built six sonar sets, but they are ready only now; no U-boat was ever hunted with them.



